Cry It Out for Puppy Crate Training? Try This Instead

Leaving a puppy to cry until they give up is not a good crate-training plan. A little protest can happen while a puppy adjusts, but prolonged crying may signal fear, discomfort, or an urgent need to go outside. Instead of setting a timer and ignoring every sound, help your puppy learn that the crate is a safe place to settle.

Choose a crate large enough for your puppy to stand, turn around, and lie down, but not so large that one end becomes a bathroom. Add safe, comfortable bedding if your puppy does not chew it, and leave the door open during early introductions. Toss a treat inside and let your puppy walk in and out without closing the door.

Check the product’s listed specifications when evaluating start with comfort, not confinement.

Feed meals near or inside the crate to create a positive association. Once your puppy enters willingly, close the door for a few seconds while you remain nearby, then reopen it before they become distressed. Gradually increase the time and your distance; if crying escalates, make the next practice session easier.

Check the product’s listed specifications when evaluating build up crate time in small steps.

A young puppy may need an overnight potty break, especially during the first weeks at home. Keep nighttime trips quiet and brief: go outside, allow time to potty, then return to the crate without starting a play session. Placing the crate near your bed can also help you notice genuine needs and reassure your puppy with your presence.

Check the product’s listed specifications when evaluating respond to nighttime crying thoughtfully.

Brief fussing that fades as your puppy settles is different from sustained screaming, frantic scratching, or attempts to escape. If your puppy seems panicked, check for potty needs or discomfort and shorten future sessions rather than waiting for exhaustion. For a fuller step-by-step approach, read our practical guide to crate training your pup.